Separating agent for optical isomer

ABSTRACT

The present invention provides a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers having no large UV absorption as represented by an aromatic group and having high asymmetric recognizability, particularly, high asymmetric recognizability in an aqueous mobile phase, or a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers comprising a polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group as an effective component.

TECHNICAL FIELD OF THE INVENTION

[0001] The present invention relates to a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers, in particular, a separating agent suitably used for separating enantiomeric isomers in chromatography. More particularly, the present invention relates to a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers that can enantiomerically resolve many kinds chiral compounds with high separation factors in the analysis of pharmaceuticals, foods, agricultural chemicals, fragrants and the like.

PRIOR ARTS

[0002] Many organic compounds have enantiomeric isomers that have the same physical and chemical properties such as boiling point, melting point, solubility and the like but show a difference in the physiological activity that influences the living body of an organism. This difference in the physiological activity between enantiomeric isomers is attributable to the following. In most cases, proteins and carbohydrates that compose the organism are composed only of the one of the enantiomeric isomers so that they show a difference in the manner of action to the other enantiomeric isomer. In the field of pharmaceutical preparations, particularly, in many cases, there are significant differences in medical effect and toxicity between the two enantiomeric isomers. Therefore, in the Guideline for the Production of Pharmaceuticals, the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare describes “when the drug of interest is a racemic modification, it is desirable to preliminarily study absorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion kinetics of each enantiomeric isomer.”

[0003] Since enantiomeric isomers have completely the same physical and chemical properties, they cannot be separated and analyzed by ordinary separation means. Therefore, extensive studies have been made on techniques for easily and precisely separating and analyzing a wide variety of enantiomeric isomers.

[0004] As a result, as an analytical technique that meets these requirements, an optical resolution method by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), in particular an optical resolution method by using a chiral column for HPLC (chiral stationary phase method) has been developed and widely spread. The chiral column referred to herein means an asymmetry recognition agent itself or a column using, as a filler, a chiral stationary phase composed of an asymmetry recognition agent supported on a suitable carrier.

[0005] As such asymmetry recognition agents, for example, optically active poly (triphenylmethylmethacrylate) (c.f., Japanese Patent Application Laid Open No. 57-150432), cellulose and amylose derivatives (Y. Okamoto, M. Kawashima and K. Hatada, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 5337, 1984), ovomucoid, which is a protein (Japanese Patent Application Laid Open No. 63-307829) and the like have been developed. It has been known that among many chiral stationary phases for HPLC, a chiral stationary phase having a cellulose or amylose derivative supported on silica gel has high asymmetry recognition ability to an extremely wide variety of compounds. Furthermore, in recent years, studies on a liquid chromatographic fractionation method for optically active substances in an industrial scale by the combination of the chiral stationary phase for HPLC with a stimulated moving bed process have been developed (Pharm Tech Japan, 12, 43 (1996). In order to not only simply perform a base line separation but also further increase productivity of chromatographic fractionation, a chiral stationary phase being capable of further separating a target compound or having as high a value of the separation factor α as possible has been desired.

[0006] Since the HPLC chiral stationary phase is frequently used under a reversed phase condition that is an aqueous mobile phase, frequent replacement between an organic solvent-based mobile phase and the aqueous mobile phase is complicated and unsuitable from the point of the maintenance of analytic equipment. It might also lead to a wrong operation by the mixing of the mobile phases. Therefore, it has been desired to perform an analysis in either one of the mobile phase systems, more preferably, in the aqueous mobile phase system. Further, in relation to the recent environmental problems, there is a trend to reduce the organic solvent discharged as mobile phase as much as possible.

[0007] As the chiral stationary phases to be used under reversed phase condition, one using the protein as asymmetry recognition agent, one using a polysaccharide derivative capable of separating a widest variety of racemic compounds as asymmetry recognition agent, and the like have been developed and marketed, and an asymmetry recognition agent having further remarkable separation characteristic has been demanded.

[0008] Recently, there is growing interest in a thin-layer chromatography (chiral TLC) for enantiomeric isomer separation capable of performing an enantiomeric isomer separation in capillary electrophoresis (CE) field or performing an enantiomeric isomer separation with a separating operation easier than HPLC. The cellulose and amylose derivative-based chiral stationary phases developed and marketed so far as HPLC chiral stationary phase are mostly formed of aromatic derivatives, except an acetate derivative, because it has been considered that the interaction between π-π electrons plays an important part in the asymmetry recognition between a substituent of a polysaccharide derivative and a solute (Society of Synthetic Organic Chemistry, 54, 344 (1996), Japanese Patent Application Laid Open No. 60-142930). However, an asymmetry recognition agent having a substituent having large UV absorptive group as aromatic group had the disadvantage in that it is not applicable to, for example, thin-layer chromatography as described above, liquid chromatographic separation comprising adding the asymmetry recognition agent to a mobile phase, micelle dynamic chromatography that is one kind of capillary electrophoreses, and the like.

[0009] This reason is that the UV absorption of an intended substance is relatively minimized so as to be undetectable when a large UV absorption as represented by the aromatic group is present in a background (corresponding to a thin layer or mobile phase) in a generally extensively used UV detector. Accordingly, a polysaccharide derivative-based asymmetry recognition agent having high asymmetric recognition ability and minimized UV absorption has been demanded so as to be applicable to the chiral CE field and chiral TLC field.

[0010] The present invention thus has an object to provide a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers free from large UV absorption as represented by an aromatic group and having high asymmetry recognition ability, particularly high asymmetry recognition ability in an aqueous mobile phase.

DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION

[0011] As a result of eager studies for achieving the above-mentioned object, the present inventors have now achieved the present invention.

[0012] Namely, the present invention provides a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers comprising a polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group as an effective component.

[0013] The polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group is concretely cellulose tris(cyclohexylcarboxylate), cellulose tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate) or cellulose tris(cycloadamantylcarboxylate).

[0014] The present invention further provides a method for separating enantiomeric isomers by a chromatography having a chiral stationary phase containing a polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group as an effective component, or a use for using a polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group as a separating agent for enantiomeric isomers.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVNETION

[0015] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail.

[0016] The polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group used in the present invention can be obtained by reacting a polysaccharide with an alicyclic compound having functional group that is reactive with the hydroxyl group of the polysaccharide to form an ester bond.

[0017] The polysaccharide used in the present invention may be any polysaccharide, being a synthetic or natural one or a modified natural one as long as it has optical activity. The polysaccharide has preferably a high regularity in the manner of binding between saccharides. Examples of the polysaccharide include β-1,4-glucan (cellulose), α-1, 4-glucan (amylose or amylopectin), α-1,6-glucan (dextran), β-1,6-glucan (pustulan), β-1,3-glucan (for example, curdlan, schizophyllan, etc.), α-1,3-glucan, β-1,2-glucan (crown gall polysaccharide), β-1,4-galactan, β-1,4-mannan, α-1,6-mannan, β-1,2-fructan (inulin), β-2,6-fructan (levan), β-1,4-xylan, β-1,3-xylan, β-1,4-chitosan, α-1,4-N-acetylchitosan (chitin), pullulan, agarose and alginic acid. Also, starches containing amylose are included therein. Among these polysaccharides, it is preferable to use cellulose, amylose, β-1,4-xylan, β-1,4-chitosan, chitin, β-1,4-mannan, inulin, curdlan, etc. which can be easily obtained as highly pure polysaccharides, still preferably cellulose.

[0018] It is preferable that such a polysaccharide has a number-average degree of polymerization (i.e., the average number of pyranose or furanose rings per molecule) of at least 5, still preferably at least 10. From the viewpoint of handling properties, it is preferable that the number-average degree of polymerization thereof is not more than 1,000, though the upper limit thereof is not particularly defined.

[0019] As the alicyclic compound having functional group capable of reacting with the hydroxyl group of the polysaccharide to form an ester bond, which is used in the present invention, any compound may be used as long as it has functional group capable of forming an ester bond, such as an acid halide having an alicyclic structure free from large UV absorption represented by aromatic group, or the like. To impart the effect for regularly aligning the polysaccharide derivative frames or substituents, an alicyclic compound having a ring larger than 3-membered ring, more preferably larger than 5-memberd ring, or an alicyclic compound having a cross-linking structure is desirable. Particularly preferable examples of the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative having no large UV absorption represented by aromatic group, which is used in the present invention, include ester derivatives of polysaccharides having at least 0.1 ester bond per glucose unit, particularly, cycloalkylcarboxylates of polysaccharides. Concretely, they include cyclohexylcarboxylate, cyclopentylcarboxylate and cycloadamantylpentylcarboxylate.

[0020] The polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group used in the present invention can be formed into an intended separating agent for enantiomeric isomers by either a method for supporting it on a carrier described below or a method for pulverizing or pelletizing the polysaccharide derivative itself.

[0021] The supporting referred to herein means that the polysaccharide derivative is fixed on the carrier. The fixation may be performed by any means as physical adsorption between the polysaccharide derivative and the carrier, chemical bond with the carrier, mutual chemical bond between polysaccharide derivatives, chemical bond of a third component, irradiation of the polysaccharide derivative, radical reaction and the like. The carriers referred to herein include porous organic carriers and porous inorganic carriers, and the porous inorganic carriers are preferable. Appropriate examples of the organic porous substrates include polymers comprising polystyrene, polyacrylamide, polyacrylate, etc. Appropriate examples of the inorganic porous substrates include silica, alumina, magnesia, glass, kaolin, titanium oxide, silicates and hydroxyapatite. Silica gel may be cited as a particularly preferable carrier. The particle diameter of the silica gel is preferably from 0.1 μm to 10 mm, and more preferably from 1 μm to 300 μm, and the average pore size thereof is from 10 angstroms to 100 μm, preferably from 50 angstroms to 50,000 angstroms. When silica gel is employed as the carrier, it is preferable to preliminarily surface-coat the silica gel so as to exterminate the effects of the silanol remaining therein, though a non-surface-treated one may be used without any problem.

[0022] The amount of the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative supported on the carrier is preferably 1 to 100 parts by weight, particularly preferably 5 to 60 parts by weight, based on 100 parts by weight of the carrier.

[0023] The pulverization or pelletization of the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative may be performed by any known method. The resulting pulverized or spherical polysaccharide derivative is used as it is or desirably made the same particle size by classification.

[0024] The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers of the present invention is preferably used as a chiral stationary phase for chromatography such as gas chromatography, liquid chromatography, thin-layer chromatography, capillary electrophoresis or the like, and further preferably used as a liquid chromatographic chiral stationary phase or thin-layer chromatographic stationary phase used under a reversed phase condition, in particular under a reversed phase condition using a mobile phase formed of a single body of water, alcohol (methanol, ethanol, etc.) or acetonitrile or a mixture containing a plurality of liquids selected therefrom, an asymmetry recognition agent added to a migrating liquid or filled in a capillary in a capillary electrophoresis such as micelle dynamic chromatography, capillary electrochromatography or the like, and a stationary phase for continuous liquid preparative chromatography such as simulated moving bed process or the like. The mobile phases used under the reversed phase system condition include those containing a pH regulator (e.g., phosphoric acid, etc.), sodium perchlorate, potassium 6-fluorophosphate, or the like.

ADVANTAGE OF THE INVENTION

[0025] According to the present invention, a polysaccharide derivative-based asymmetry recognition agent with high asymmetry recognition ability and minimized UV absorption, that is suitably used as a HPLC chiral stationary phase under a reversed phase condition using an aqueous mobile phase or in chiral CE field, chiral TLC field and the like can be provided.

EXAMPLES

[0026] The present invention will be further described in more detail by way of examples. However, the present invention should not be construed as being limited to these examples. The capacity factor (k′) and separation factor (α) in the examples are defined by the following equations.

[0027] Capacity factor;

k′=[(Retention time of enantiomer)−(Dead time)]/(Dead time)

[0028] Separation Factor;

α=(Capacity factor of more strongly absorbed enantiomer)/(Capacity factor of more weakly absorbed enantiomer)

[0029] The elution time of acetonitrile was taken as the dead time.

Example 1

[0030] Production of Cellulose

[0031] Tris(cyclohexylcarboxylate)-Supported Filler and Packed Column

[0032] (1) Synthesis of Cellulose Tris(cyclohexylcarboxylate) (a) To 15 ml of N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), 1.5 g of vacuum-dried lithium chloride was dissolved to prepare a DMAc/LiCl solution.

[0033] Under a nitrogen atmosphere, 15 ml of the above DMAc/LiCl solution and 15 ml of pyridine were added to 1.0 g of cellulose, and the resulting mixture was dipped in an oil bath at 100° C. and stirred for 24 hrs. Thereafter, 4.8 g of chloride cyclohexylcarboxylate (C₆H₁₁COCl) (34 mmol, 1.8 equivalents) was added thereto and reacted for 16 hrs at 100° C. The resulting solution was dripped in 200 ml of methanol and reprecipitated followed by centrifugal precipitation. As a result, the intended ester derivative (2.8 g, 93%) was obtained. The elemental analytic result of the resulting ester derivative (a) is shown in Table 1. TABLE 1 Elemental Analytic Result of Cellulose Tris (cyclohexylcarboxylate) (a) C (%) H (%) N (%) Calculated Value 65.83 8.18 0.00 Measured Value 65.82 8.22 0.07

[0034] (2) Production of Filler With Cellulose Tris(cyclohexylcarboxylate) Supported Thereon

[0035] To 10 ml of tetrahydrofurane (THF), 0.75 g of the ester derivative obtained in (1) was dissolved. The THF solution of the ester derivative was uniformly sprinkled on 3.0 g of silica gel treated with aminopropyl silane (particle size 7 μm, pore diameter 1000 Å), and the solvent was removed, whereby a filler with cellulose tris (cyclohexylcarboxylate) supported thereon was prepared.

[0036] (3) Production of Packed Column Using Cellulose Tris(cyclohexylcarboxylate)-Supported Filler

[0037] The supported filler obtained in (2) was filled in a stainless column of φ0.46 cm×L25 cm with pressurizing by slurry filling method to form an enantiomeric isomer separation column.

Comparative Example 1

[0038] Production of Cellulose Triacetate-Supported Filler and Packed Column

[0039] (1) Synthesis of Cellulose Triacetate

[0040] Under a nitrogen atmosphere, 40 ml of acetic anhydride was added to 1.0 g of cellulose and reacted at 100° C. for 30 hrs. After the reaction, the resulting solution was allowed to stand cool to room temperature, and pored into 500 ml of methanol to precipitate cellulose triacetate. Grass filter filtration was then performed, and the filtrate was sufficiently washed with methanol and vacuum dried at 60° C. for 5 hrs. As a result, the intended cellulose triacetate was obtained (1.69 g, Yield 95%).

[0041] (2) Production of Filler with Cellulose Triacetate Supported Thereon

[0042] To 10 ml of methylene chloride, 1.0 g of the cellulose triacetate obtained in (1) was dissolved. The resulting solution was uniformly sprinkled on 3.0 g of silica gel treated with aminopropyl silane (particle size 7 μm, pore diameter 1000 Å) , and the solvent was removed, whereby a filler with cellulose triacetate supported thereon was produced.

[0043] (3) Production of Packed Column Using Cellulose Triacetate-Supported Filler

[0044] The supported filler formed in (2) was filled in a stainless column of φ0.46 cm×L25 cm with pressurizing by slurry filling method to prepare an enantiomeric isomer separation column for comparison.

Comparative Example 2

[0045] Production of Cellulose Tribenzoate-Supported Filler and Packed column

[0046] (1) Synthesis of Cellulose Tribenzoate

[0047] Under a nitrogen atmosphere, 40 ml of pyridine was added to 1.0 g of cellulose, 6.5 g of benzoyl chloride was added thereto, and the mixture was reacted at 100° C. for 30 hrs. After the reaction, the resulting solution was allowed to stand cool to room temperature and poured into 500 ml of methanol to precipitate cellulose tribenzoate. Glass filter filtration was then performed, and the filtrate was sufficiently washed with methanol and vacuum dried at 60° C. for 5 hrs. As a result, the intended cellulose tribenzoate was obtained (2.49 g, Yield 85%).

[0048] (2) Production of Filler With Cellulose Tribenzoate Supported Thereon

[0049] To 10 ml of methylene chloride, 1.0 g of the cellulose tribenzoate obtained in (1) was dissolved. The resulting solution was uniformly sprinkled on 3.0 g of silica gel treated with aminopropyl silane (particle size 7 μm, pore diameter 1000 Å), and the solvent was removed, whereby a filler with cellulose tribenzoate supported thereon was prepared.

[0050] (3) Production of Packed Column Using Cellulose Tribenzoate-Supported Filler

[0051] The supported filler obtained in (2) was filled in a stainless column of φ0.46 cm×L25 cm with pressurizing by slurry filling method to form an enantiomeric isomer separation column for comparison.

Applied Example 1

[0052] The enantiomeric isomer separation columns obtained in Example 1 and Comparative Examples 1-2 were used to perform the evaluation of asymmetry recognition ability for racemic modifications 1 and 2 represented by the following formulae by a liquid chromatography of the following condition. The result is shown in Table 2.

[0053] <Liquid Chromatographic Condition> Example 1: H₂O/MeOH = 2.8 (v/v) Mobile Phase Comparative Examples 1 and 2: MeOH Flow Velocity 0.5 ml/min Temperature 25° C.

[0054] TABLE 2

Separating Agent Separation Factor (α) Comparative Comparative Racemic Modification Example 1 Example 1 Example 2 Racemic Modification 1 1.64 1.0 1.37 Racemic Modification 2 1.16 1.0 1.0

Example 2

[0055] Production of Cellulose Tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate)-Supported Filler and Packed Column

[0056] (1) Synthesis of Cellulose Tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate) (d)

[0057] To 15 ml of N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), 1.5 g of vacuum-dried lithium chloride was dissolved to prepare a DMAc/LiCl solution.

[0058] Under a nitrogen atmosphere, 15 ml of the DMAc/LiCl solution and 15 ml of pyridine were added to 1.0 g of cellulose, and the mixture was dipped in a hot water bath at 100° C. and stirred for 24 hrs. Thereafter, 4.4 g of chloride cyclopentylcarboxylate (33 mmol, 1.8 equivalent) was added thereto and reacted at 100° C. for 16 hrs. The reaction dope was poured into 200 ml of MeOH and reprecipitated followed by centrifugal separation. As a result, the intended ester derivative was obtained (2.5 g, 90%). The elementary analytic result of (d) is shown in Table 3.

[0059] (2) Production of Filler With Cellulose Tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate) Supported Thereon

[0060] To 10 ml of tetrahydrofurane (THF), 1.0 g of the ester derivative obtained in (1) was dissolved. The THF solution of the cellulose ester derivative was uniformly sprinkled on 3.0 g of silica gel treated with aminopropyl silane (particle size 7 μm, pore diameter 1000 Å), and the solvent was removed, whereby a filler with cellulose tris (cyclopentylcarboxylate) supported thereon was produced.

[0061] (3) Production of Packed Column Using Cellulose Tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate)-Supported Filler

[0062] The supported filler obtained in (2) was filled in a stainless column of φ0.46 cm×L25 cm with pressurizing by slurry filling method to prepare an enantiomeric isomer separation column.

Example 3

[0063] Production of Cellulose Tris(1-adamantylcarboxylate) Supported Filler and Packed Column

[0064] (1) Synthesis of Cellulose Tris(1-adamantylcarboxylate) (e)

[0065] To 15 ml of N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc), 1.5 g of vacuum-dried lithium chloride 1.5 g was dissolved to prepare a DMAc/LiCl solution.

[0066] Under a nitrogen atmosphere, 15 ml of the DMAc/LiCl solution and 15 ml of pyridine were added to 1.0 g of cellulose, and the mixture was dipped in a hot water bath at 100° C. and stirred for 24 hrs. Thereafter, 9.2 g of chloride 1-adamantylcarboxylate (46 mmol, 2.5 equivalent) was added thereto and reacted at 100° C. for 48 hrs. The reaction dope was poured into 200 ml of MeOH and reprecipitated followed by centrifugal separation. As a result, the intended ester derivative was obtained (3.2 g, 80%). The elementary analytic result of (e) is shown in Table 3.

[0067] (2) Production of Filler With Cellulose Tris(1-adamantylcarboxylate) Supported Thereon

[0068] To 10 ml of tetrahydrofurane (THF), 1.0 g of the ester derivative obtained in (1) was dissolved. The THF solution of the cellulose derivative was uniformly sprinkled on 3.0 g of silica gel treated with aminopropylsilane (particle size 7 μm, pore diameter 1000 Å), and the solvent was removed, whereby a filler with cellulose tris(1-adamantylcarobxylate) supported thereon was produced.

[0069] (3) Production of Packed Column Using Cellulose Tris(1-adamantylcarboxylate)-Supported Filler

[0070] The supported filler obtained in (2) was filled in a stainless column of φ0.46 cm×L25 cm with pressurizing by slurry filling method to prepare an enantiomeric isomer separation column. TABLE 3 Elementary Analytic Result of Cellulose Tris (cyclopentylcarboxylate) and Cellulose Tris (1-adamantylcarboxylate) C (%) H (%) N (%) (d) Calculated Value 63.98 7.61 0.00 (d) Measured Value 63.45 7.51 0.04 (e) Calculated Value 72.19 8.08 0.00 (e) Measured Value 69.50 7.97 0.11

[0071] Applied Examples 2 and 3

[0072] The enantiomeric isomer separation columns produced in Examples 2 and 3 were used to perform the evaluation of asymmetry recognition ability for the racemic modifications 1 and 2 used in Applied Example 1 by liquid chromatography in the same manner as in Applied Example 1. The result is shown in Table 4. TABLE 4 Separation Factor α of Columns Formed in Examples 2 and 3 Separating Agent Racemic Modification Example 2 Example 3 Racemic Modification 1 1.34 1.19 Racemic Modification 2 1.17 1.07

[0073] Analytic Condition: H₂O/MeOH=2/8 (v/v); Flow Velocity 0.4 ml/min; Temperature 25° C. 

1. A separating agent for enantiomeric isomers comprising a polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group as an effective component.
 2. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 1 wherein the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative is a cellulose derivative.
 3. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to one of claims 1 and 2 wherein the alicyclic ester derivative is a cycloalkylcarboxylate derivative.
 4. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to any one of claims 1 to 3, which is used as a chiral stationary phase for chromatography.
 5. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 4 wherein the chiral stationary phase for chromatography is a chiral stationary phase for liquid chromatography used under a reversed phase condition.
 6. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 5 wherein the reversed phase condition is a condition having a mobile phase consisting of water, alcohol or acetonitrile alone or a mixture containing a plurality of liquids selected therefrom.
 7. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 4 wherein the chiral stationary phase for chromatography is a stationary phase for thin-layer chromatography.
 8. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 4 wherein the chiral stationary phase for chromatography is an asymmetry recognition agent added to a migrating liquid of capillary electrophoresis or filled in a capillary.
 9. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 4 wherein the chiral stationary phase for chromatography is a stationary phase for continuous liquid preparative chromatography.
 10. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 1 wherein the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative is cellulose tris(cyclohexylcarboxylate).
 11. The separating agent for enantiomeric isomers according to claim 1 wherein the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative is cellulose tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate) or cellulose tris(cycloadamantylcarboxylate).
 12. A method for separating enantiomeric isomers by a chromatography having a chiral stationary phase containing a polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative free from aromatic group as an effective component.
 13. The method according to claim 12 wherein the polysaccharide alicyclic ester derivative is cellulose tris(cyclopentylcarboxylate) or cellulose tris(cycloadamantylcarboxylate). 